Cleveland Browns quarterback Deshaun Watson's recent Achilles surgery following a re-rupture raises significant questions about his availability for the 2025 season and the team's future direction. The setback, confirmed by Browns general manager Andrew Berry, comes after Watson initially tore his Achilles in October. This leaves the Browns in a precarious position regarding their quarterback situation.

With Watson's future uncertain, the Browns may need to explore other options, including the NFL Draft and free agency. Holding the No. 2 overall pick, they could potentially target top quarterback prospects like Shedeur Sanders or Cam Ward if available. This situation is further complicated by the substantial investment the Browns made in acquiring Watson from the Houston Texans, including multiple first-round draft picks and a lucrative, fully guaranteed five-year, $230 million contract.

Watson's performance and off-field issues have made the contract a significant burden for the team. He has played in only 19 games over three seasons with the Browns, including an 11-game suspension stemming from allegations of sexual assault and inappropriate conduct. His on-field performance before the injury this season was also underwhelming, with a 63.4% completion rate, five touchdowns, and three interceptions in seven starts, leading to a 1-6 record during that span.

Adding to the Browns' woes, former quarterback Baker Mayfield, whom they traded to make way for Watson, has found success with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, leading them to consecutive NFC South titles. This contrast further highlights the challenges facing the Browns. Depending on the outcome of Watson's recovery and the team's offseason moves, it's possible that Watson has played his last game for Cleveland.