Oakland, California, finds itself grappling with a public safety crisis, leaving residents feeling vulnerable and businesses struggling. Seneca Scott, a community activist and founder of Neighbors Together Oakland, points to the failed "defund the police" movement as a key factor in the city's escalating crime rates and the decline in public safety.

Scott criticizes the policies of "neo-progressives" in local government, arguing that their approach has created a "dangerous doom loop" where residents feel unsafe, businesses are closing, and crime is rampant. He highlights the stark reality of daily life in Oakland, citing numerous violent incidents occurring before noon on a typical day.

Statistics paint a grim picture of Oakland's public safety challenges. The city experienced nearly 500 homicides between 2018 and 2022, earning it the unfortunate distinction of being the most dangerous city in the Bay Area. Recent weekly crime data reveals hundreds of incidents, including larcenies, vehicle thefts, robberies, assaults, and burglaries.

Compounding the issue is the struggling 911 dispatch system. Scott points out chronic understaffing and high turnover among dispatchers, leading to unacceptable wait times for emergency assistance. The system has experienced multiple failures recently, and data shows that Oakland police are falling far short of state standards for answering 911 calls promptly. In June, their average answer time was the worst in the state, exceeding one minute.

Scott argues that the lack of effective law enforcement has made Oakland a target for organized crime and other criminal activities. He emphasizes the devastating impact of these crimes on residents, particularly those in low-income communities, perpetuating a cycle of poverty. The fear of crime keeps people indoors, hurting local businesses and exacerbating economic hardship.

Scott believes the solution lies in electing new leaders who prioritize public safety and take a tougher stance on crime. He sees a glimmer of hope in the recent efforts to recall Alameda County District Attorney Pamela Price, whose progressive policies have drawn criticism for contributing to the rise in crime. Critics argue that her leniency towards young offenders and reluctance to use sentencing enhancements have emboldened criminals.

Scott warns that without significant change, Oakland risks becoming one of the most unlivable cities in the country. He emphasizes the urgent need for action to address the city's public safety crisis and restore a sense of security for its residents and businesses.